Published by Dutton Books for Young Readers
Summary: Osh found Crow as a baby, when the dilapidated skiff she was riding in washed up on his tiny island off the coast of Massachusetts. At age 12, Crow begins to want to know more about her past. Rumor has it she came from Penikese, the island that used to house a leper colony, and this causes most of her neighbors to shun her. One notable exception is Miss Maggie, a neighbor who is like a mother to Crow. Osh, Miss Maggie, and Crow take a trip to Penikese to try to find clues about her past, and meet up with a nasty man who claims to be in charge of the bird sanctuary there. This trip and their encounter begin a chain of events that eventually include buried treasure, a violent crime, shipwreck, a long-lost brother, and Crow’s discoveries about her families…both the one that gave her up and the one that has loved her all along. 304 pages; grades 4-8.
Pros: Lauren Wolk’s follow-up to her Newbery honor Wolf Hollow does not disappoint in the least. The story is well-paced, with fascinating details about life on the Elizabeth islands in the 1920’s, and well-developed characters. Readers will take Crow, Osh, and Miss Maggie to heart, and enjoy the secrets that are slowly revealed as the story unfolds.
Cons: Here it is the end of July, and this is only the second Newbery contender I’ve read this year and the first for fiction (I’m keeping my fingers crossed for Undefeated by Steven Sheinkin). Anyone else have any thoughts about this? Leave a comment if you’ve read something else that you think is Newbery-worthy this year.