Published by Viking
Summary: Katy Gordon is the star pitcher of her 1957 neighborhood baseball team. One afternoon, wearing a jersey and cap and being called “Gordon” by the boys, she’s invited by a Little League scout to a tryout. She makes the team, but when one of the other boys tells the coach that she’s a girl, she’s promptly kicked off. Supported by her chemistry professor mother, she writes to Little League headquarters, but receives a disappointing response that includes the sentence, “Since the beginning of baseball as an organized sport, it has always been the sole province of male athletes.” When Katy is assigned a research project at school, she decides to research women in baseball and is shocked to learn how many women have played since the beginning of the game. Her project gets her some local attention, a story in the paper, and the chance to strike out Willie Mays, but even that isn’t enough to get her back into Little League. In the end, she’s back to the neighborhood team; the final scene shows her reaching out to a younger girl who wants to play as well. Includes information about the women Katy researches; an author’s note; a glossary; and additional resources. 320 pages; grades 4-7.
Pros: Katy is a spunky narrator who will have boys and girls rooting for her in her campaign against the unfair Little League rules. There are plenty of other interesting historical details, from Katy’s mother’s fight against McCarthyism at her university job to Katy receiving one of the new Frisbees for her birthday.
Cons: On page 245, Katy’s friend Jules dismisses the Nancy Drew mysteries in this way: “They’re all about the same. Nancy has adventures, her chums get into trouble, Ned rescues them all (emphasis mine), and the mystery gets solved along the way.” Having read more than 40 Nancy Drew books in my childhood, I feel safe in saying Nancy rescued Ned at least as often as the other way around.