Published by Arthur A. Levine Books
Summary: Sylvie and Miranda have been best friends just about their whole lives. But now a new boy in the neighborhood, Georgie, is becoming friends with Miranda, and Sylvie is worried that she’s losing her friend. She decides that Miranda’s upcoming birthday party is her chance to prove what a good friend she is by giving the most spectacular present she can find. Her misguided attempts result in a stolen ferret, a twisted ankle, and an enormous cardboard castle covered with glitter glue. Will Miranda appreciate Sylvie’s efforts, or is their friendship doomed to come to an end? Grades 2-4.
Pros: Sylvie is a likable character with worries and self-doubts that many kids will relate to. Her clumsy but heartfelt efforts at friendship will engage beginning chapter book readers. Look for the sequel, Mean Girl Meltdown.
Cons: The stolen ferret storyline made me anxious.