Published by Candlewick
Summary: A girl tries to stall bedtime by asking a series of difficult questions, but her father is always one step ahead of her. “Why is the ocean blue?” “Every night, when you go to sleep, the fish take out guitars. They sing sad songs and cry blue tears.” While none of the answers is accurate, they show a great deal of imagination. When the girl explodes with sixteen questions on a two-page spread, her father tells her it’s time to go to sleep. Why? “Because there are some things we can only see with our eyes closed.” 40 pages; ages 4-8.
Pros: I love Mac Barnett–who doesn’t?–but my favorite part of this book is Isabelle Arsenault’s illustrations, brimming with imagination but with a muted palette perfect for nighttime. Showing a jumble of shells, animals, planets, and a guitar in the girl’s bedroom hints at the inquisitive minds that are part of this family. A perfect bedtime story.
Cons: All those marbles scattered on the floor seem like a nighttime hazard.